Red Sky at Morning
Superstar
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2017
- Messages
- 14,633
I'll leave you to it.He didn't say that it didn't happen
I'll leave you to it.He didn't say that it didn't happen
There used to be a blog that researched old newspapers on the subject. Unfortunately, it is not set to private although you can still do a basic search that will show you how the number 6 million was used to describe everything from the number of Jews in bread lines to the number of Jews, to the number of Jews in peril. It was used over and over and over again in the newspaper in the beginning of the century. It is more than a little coincidental that the number is used so many, many times to describe the Jews.Very thought provoking.
So we're in agreement that the holocaust occurred, but the argument you're bringing forward is one I haven't come across before.
It does make sense, by making it seem like the one single event in history to cause such devastation, it has not only allowed the creation of Israel (and the displacement of Palestinians) but it kind of allows Israel to get away with what it wants. Anyone who criticises Israel is labelled an anti semite which is quite ridiculous; the state of Israel and the Jewish faith are too entirely different things.
You can have a Jew that supports Israel but critiquing Israel isn't anti-Semitic. If you criticise Judaism, you're labelled anti semitic, however, I don't believe it should be a protected faith, people criticise Islam and Christianity on a daily basis yet Judaism is never in the midst of a debate. Either all religions should be protected, or none. In a secular society I do welcome the freedom to critique a faith but it shouldn't be an excuse to use derogatory language. Unfortunately, people don't possess the linguistic capabilities to form a cohesive and transparent argument. Word choice is key, we all know what words cause offence and as long as we stand within the perimeters of deemable language, there's no reason why we can't have a healthy discussion about faith.
Of course discriminatory remarks against Judaism is anti-Semitic however inflammatory remarks are made about Islam and other faiths all the time, yet no one bats an eyelid. God forbid you even an utter a word about Judaism, you're leapt on like a leech and called an anti-Semitic.
Personally, I believe many people are anti-Zionist and anti-Israel due to the way Israel acquired 'their land'. Also, their actions since acquiring the land have been diabolical and we can't really sit here and ignore that. They've pretty much decimated the Palestinian region and the Zionist loving BBC, along with other news outlets, will never report the extent of the true damage they have done.
Your linguistic skills are formidable and im glad you get me , i agree 100% with all you said here.Very thought provoking.
So we're in agreement that the holocaust occurred, but the argument you're bringing forward is one I haven't come across before.
It does make sense, by making it seem like the one single event in history to cause such devastation, it has not only allowed the creation of Israel (and the displacement of Palestinians) but it kind of allows Israel to get away with what it wants. Anyone who criticises Israel is labelled an anti semite which is quite ridiculous; the state of Israel and the Jewish faith are too entirely different things.
You can have a Jew that supports Israel but critiquing Israel isn't anti-Semitic. If you criticise Judaism, you're labelled anti semitic, however, I don't believe it should be a protected faith, people criticise Islam and Christianity on a daily basis yet Judaism is never in the midst of a debate. Either all religions should be protected, or none. In a secular society I do welcome the freedom to critique a faith but it shouldn't be an excuse to use derogatory language. Unfortunately, people don't possess the linguistic capabilities to form a cohesive and transparent argument. Word choice is key, we all know what words cause offence and as long as we stand within the perimeters of deemable language, there's no reason why we can't have a healthy discussion about faith.
Of course discriminatory remarks against Judaism is anti-Semitic however inflammatory remarks are made about Islam and other faiths all the time, yet no one bats an eyelid. God forbid you even an utter a word about Judaism, you're leapt on like a leech and called an anti-Semitic.
Personally, I believe many people are anti-Zionist and anti-Israel due to the way Israel acquired 'their land'. Also, their actions since acquiring the land have been diabolical and we can't really sit here and ignore that. They've pretty much decimated the Palestinian region and the Zionist loving BBC, along with other news outlets, will never report the extent of the true damage they have done.
I never said it didnt happend... it did happen ... horrific things .... that was not the point... try reading againMy grandfather went to some Eastern European camps after ww2.
It happened.
May you never come to see the things he described.
There clearly is/was propaganda regarding the numbers.There used to be a blog that researched old newspapers on the subject. Unfortunately, it is not set to private although you can still do a basic search that will show you how the number 6 million was used to describe everything from the number of Jews in bread lines to the number of Jews, to the number of Jews in peril. It was used over and over and over again in the newspaper in the beginning of the century. It is more than a little coincidental that the number is used so many, many times to describe the Jews.
http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=six+million+jews+newspaper&FORM=HDRSC2
In reality, there is a lot more than the 6 million figure that makes propaganda regarding the holocaust suspect. Not that the holocaust didn't happen of course. It is just that there is obviously a lot of propaganda regarding it that can be seen from even a basic search of old newspaper images.
Thats my point ... The holocaust did happen but it was greatly inflated to serve a purpose....There used to be a blog that researched old newspapers on the subject. Unfortunately, it is not set to private although you can still do a basic search that will show you how the number 6 million was used to describe everything from the number of Jews in bread lines to the number of Jews, to the number of Jews in peril. It was used over and over and over again in the newspaper in the beginning of the century. It is more than a little coincidental that the number is used so many, many times to describe the Jews.
http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=six+million+jews+newspaper&FORM=HDRSC2
In reality, there is a lot more than the 6 million figure that makes propaganda regarding the holocaust suspect. Not that the holocaust didn't happen of course. It is just that there is obviously a lot of propaganda regarding it that can be seen from even a basic search of old newspaper images.
I believe you that you are of a Jewish background. It does not make any difference objectively what background you have.Keep in mind that I was a jew, I quit after I found out the base of my religion is worshiping the devil - LOL -
If you would tell me 2 years ago the things I'm telling you now I would go nuts and beat you up.
Keep in mind that millions did die, the lie is the gas chambers and the 6 million figure.,and the "fact" that the jews are somewhat the most victimized people in history without any fault.
With hours of carefully captured videos of piles of dead people and horrible conditions backed by media-army-government propaganda, i can make the holocaust seem as if 200 billion people died.
I see you are asking for SERIOUS EVIDENCEUnless you have serious evidence that disproves multiple information sources I cannot take your claims seriously.
I agree and I will withdraw. I am exceptionally closeminded when there is overwhelming proof for the opposite position.I see you are asking for SERIOUS EVIDENCE
I'm sorry but serious evidence is almost impossible to get, the powers that govern the western world had made sure to make absolute evidence gathering almost impossible.
If you cant relate to my ideas then let's agree to disagree.
I'm sure we"ll find some common subjects in the future.
I understand, believe me, there is nothing more satisfying than having a great debate with hard argument from both sides, but there are topics that it cannot be done in that way.I agree and I will withdraw. I am exceptionally closeminded when there is overwhelming proof for the opposite position.
No it's not my friend, I love Israel and all its people, jews and Muslim and Christians.What was this thread about again, anti-israelism?
whats this "politeness" thing? ive never heard of it!If you cant relate to my ideas then let's agree to disagree.
I'm sure we"ll find some common subjects in the future.
Reading your posts Antipapirus, you remind me of the modern day Benjamin Freedman. Which leads me to ask, have you ever listened to his speech, or read his letter to Dr. Goldstein?I see you are asking for SERIOUS EVIDENCE
I'm sorry but serious evidence is almost impossible to get, the powers that govern the western world had made sure to make absolute evidence gathering almost impossible.
If you cant relate to my ideas then let's agree to disagree.
I'm sure we"ll find some common subjects in the future.
this is so important, what you say.I believe it to be true because I educated my self hard and long and I choose to believe it based on the belief that i can make my own mind and reach conclusions, NOT EVERYTHING HAS TO HAVE TOTAL PROOF IN ORDER TO EXIST
No i have not, but im always glad to receive new info, i will check it out.Reading your posts Antipapirus, you remind me of the modern day Benjamin Freedman. Which leads me to ask, have you ever listened to his speech, or read his letter to Dr. Goldstein?
Reading your posts Antipapirus, you remind me of the modern day Benjamin Freedman. Which leads me to ask, have you ever listened to his speech, or read his letter to Dr. Goldstein?