Actually. No, not really. When the people on this site have attacked this thread and the people taking part in it, it was done in the belief that we supported killing civilians, taking civilians hostages and that is just not true. Your own peeve seems to be that those two things mentioned above are against the laws of war according to Islam and that's what i was responding to. However since i didn't make that clear then i will concede, in part, your point.
In your opinion were the attacks of Oct 7 on military personnel legitimate?
It should also be pointed out that on the day of Oct 7 and the days after, no one in this thread cheered or glorified what was being reported. What you will find is that, apart from reports of the alleged happenings, most people were discussing whether this was A) a false flag op. B) An attack that the Israelis knew was going to happen and allowed it to happen or C) Hamas and the Israelis colluded together. You and others were adamant that C was the correct version of events. In fact i seem to remember that when VC produced his opinion on events of Oct 7 the majority of folks who were claiming that this thread "glorified Hamas" were all pointing out how great his article was, including you. The simple fact of that matter was that most of what VC wrote had already been reported and discussed in this thread. But somehow VC great this thread bad...how come?