First of all, why you
@student brought this topic up?
what are you up to?
what is your motive for doing such a thing?
and what is your point?
Secondly, Shia believe there is only One True God and they believe Mohammad is the last messenger of God Almighty.
Third point is: the Shia scholars say cursing Aisha or the caliphs is a sin while the Shia common folk curse them so that means we should take the Shia beliefs from their scholars not the common people.
fourth point is : if they hide what is in their hearts of cursing and hating (taqeeyah, which is forbidden in Sunni view) then God knows what is hidden in the hearts and the Shia are accountable for their deeds.
Fifth point is that, i strongly disagree with their occult views about the thousand+ years living of Mahdi and the 'infallibility' of imams and the "al-Jafr" etc...
sixth, you
@Ali.Isa have already cursed Muawiah, a companion of The Prophet (PBUH) for sinning while it is not allowed to curse a believer for sinning even if it is Kabeerah sin.
seventh, i have a question from you mr
@Ali.Isa more than 80% of Syria is Sunni, they have the right to chose their leader, then what was Qasim Sulimani doing in there ?
Syria is the land of Syrians not Iranians. if you say there is 75% Shia in Bahrain and they have the right to chose their leader then why 80% Sunnis are being murdered by Shia for practicing their right?
Salam, thanks for asking, if we write properly and honestly discuss for the sake of truth we would certainly be guided. There is alot i do not agree in your post and much misconception there.
You are basically not saying anything to the member 'student' and even reject his great lies and behaviour; a person that more or less had an upbringing to hate shia and act against shia, think whatever he heard as youth is true because he is in that anti-shia environment. So unfair! PS. am not saying bad about his personality and self but his way of behaviour that is secondary in nature.
Both shia and sunni believe in Oneness of Allah - Prophethood and judgement day. The most important is judgement day why not mention it. Moreover from both sides great scholars do not believe that wahabism created by england is an islamic 'sect'.
The common folk do not curse or are unliterate in this subject and are maybe warmed up by fake shia created by england the same way isis was but differently. Imam Khamenei and all Maraje have verdict not to say bad about the Holy figures of any religion let alone Islam; this is part of our belief not some slogan and doing taqiyyah. Do you think the followers of Imam Khomeini both verdict wise and those that love him and are mostly educated would do such a think. Certainly its a duty to act against such an action that makes Muslims divided and are in favour of wahabism and arrogant powers in the world, what has taqiyah to do with this. english.khamenei.ir
Yes we should take religion from scholars of religion why you not say atleast this to 'student' member here. So anybody wears clerical or priest clothes are scholars of religion! Look at those old videos and expired propaganda produced by the enemies of Islam and Satan. Its weird nobody until now has commented very clearly against those videos (have read all the comments before posting)
So your 4th point on taqiyah issue; one can see the proof of both sides and than decide, nothing difficult to be confused. People can go and research. Everyone is accountable for their deeds specially the one that put the first post. Why neglecting resurrection issue. Thinking on judgement makes one awaken and with plan, advance towards Allah. Those that hide their real material motives; things in their heart and have sickness in their heart is mentioned in the Holy Quran and those are the hypocrites. Knowing and recognizing hypocrites is possible but very difficult.
We believe that a person can live long and there is verses in the Holy Quran in favour of infallibility and Prophets living long.
The definition who is considered a companion of Prophet Mohammad Peace Upon Him & His Family should be discussed and viewed. Actually discussion is not needed to figure which definition and explanation is intellectual we need to just present instead of carelessly misjudging around the issue and creating more misconception or the continuation of misconception. You bring forward the sunni definition that is affected by Ummayad dynasty and muawiyah Curse Upon Him lineage and i bring the shia view.
Muawiyah Curse Upon Him is not of companions of Prophet Mohammad Peace Upon Him & His Family, it would be shame and a great and legal excuse not to accrpt Islam as Religion. He was a hypocrite and after the love of world. But you know what they teach in saudi arabia to youths the teachers simply say he asked forgiveness somehow just right before his death so he is of those in paradise. Very lame indeed and you should know we believe both in Prophets ascension-Meraj and saw hell and paradise; so already build his hell by way of living in this world.
So how its okay to use [PBUH] on good people but its not okay to use the opposite for very bad people with no hope of return. I have not done sin specially greater sins. You can study about greater sins here by Ayatollah Dastghaib who got martyred/terrored in moske while leading the prayer by hypocrites that one of them is masih alinejad that the member 'student' quoted and posted about the shrine issue from her.
https://www.al-islam.org/greater-sins-volume-1-sayyid-abdul-husayn-dastghaib-shirazi
From you, just read it and see so shallow and so much not knowing and so little research: "seventh, i have a question from you mr
@Ali.Isa more than 80% of Syria is Sunni, they have the right to chose their leader, then what was Qasim Sulimani doing in there ?
Syria is the land of Syrians not Iranians. if you say there is 75% Shia in Bahrain and they have the right to chose their leader then why 80% Sunnis are being murdered by Shia for practicing their right?"
There is no need to say mr. before my name call me just Ali Isa. Isa is in arabic the name Jesus Peace Upon Him that lived very simple life and Imam Ali Peace Upon Him was very alike Him. Very syncronized personalities if one reads about their life.
Thanks for question: What has it to do with sunni and shia the small groups like al-qaeda got big and become isis the name of one of egyptian gods that zions favour and love. What is america doing in islamic countries why you not ask that question of yourself and ponder around the issue. Wahabism killed everyone from Muslims to Christians (alot of Christians compared to other beliefs) and other beliefs in those places and destroyed from Holy Shrine to actual tourist destination of example Palmyra and of course selling and making money. Iran and Syria have strategic alliance long term and Syria invited Iran army for advice and training, unlike america and american president that goes and violates iraq and afghanistan without letting the authorities and have bases mostly in germany and around the islamic countries.
No sunni is getting murdered seriously where do you get these facts even fox news do not say such bashful facts.
Bahrain belonged to Iran historically and now when the Islamic Awakening happened they didnt want a dictator someone that listens to america so actually shias are being killed and imprisoned in Bahrain by saudi army and the saudi army killing shia and sunni in Yemen.
Syria has border to lebanon and palestine; they arrogant powers wanted to cut ties but was not successful and now Islamic Republic of Iran is more powerful than ever before and aiming on kicking out america from West and Central Asia.
Video on ISIS; VERH INFORMATED, recommended for all.
islamqa.org
