Atheists And Morality

Joined
May 12, 2019
Messages
1,607
I haven’t said anything about incest actually because I’m not obsessed with it as you are. It is wrong in virtually every case because it will come with a power imbalance and coercion. Especially with family you are raised with in the same household.
From an atheist perspective, in order to suggest there is a power imbalance in an act of incest (and that this is the basis on which we ought to condemn it) you would first have to establish:
1. What is power? Power is difficult to define philsophically, and its connotations are unclear. Robert Dahl argued it is when person A has the the ability to cause person B to carry out an action, that they would not otherwise do.
2. You would have to establish that this imbalance of power exists, and then find out how it exists in this way in the relationship. It may very well be the case that there is no coercion involved, and that it is a voluntary, consensual act.

Therefore, we cannot use the axiom 'do no harm' to condemn incest, because we cannot accurately assess the extent of the involvement of power in such a relationship. Arguing for an 'imbalance of balance' to justify a condemnation of incest is tenuous and vague. However, from an objective moral standpoint, it can be condemned outright as a moral evil.
 
Last edited:

Tidal

Star
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,803
Incidentally, for years I've been asking atheists and nonchristians what exactly did Jesus say that they don't like, but I've never, ever, had a reply.
Anybody here wanna give it a shot?.. :p
 

justjess

Superstar
Joined
Mar 16, 2017
Messages
11,510
Incidentally, for years I've been asking atheists and nonchristians what exactly did Jesus say that they don't like, but I've never, ever, had a reply.
Anybody here wanna give it a shot?.. :p
Why does there have to be something jesus said that people don’t like?
 

Tidal

Star
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,803
Why does there have to be something jesus said that people don’t like?

When I first heard Elvis in the 1950's he blew my socks off and I've liked him ever since and call myself an Elvis fan.
Same with Jesus, the things he said blew my socks off too and I call myself a Christian.
If atheists liked him, they'd call themselves Christians too..:p
JC in action-

High Priest- "Jesus of Nazareth alias the Christ, the Messiah and the Son of God, you stand accused of upsetting us real bad, how do you plead?"
Jesus- "ON YER BIKE JACK!"

 

justjess

Superstar
Joined
Mar 16, 2017
Messages
11,510
When I first heard Elvis in the 1950's he blew my socks off and I've liked him ever since and call myself an Elvis fan.
Same with Jesus, the things he said blew my socks off too and I call myself a Christian.
If atheists liked him, they'd call themselves Christians too..:p
JC in action-

High Priest- "Jesus of Nazareth alias the Christ, the Messiah and the Son of God, you stand accused of upsetting us real bad, how do you plead?"
Jesus- "ON YER BIKE JACK!"

Yeah that’s not true. The Bible is way more then Jesus. There are people who follow Jesus and aren’t “Christians.” You oversimplify things
 

Tidal

Star
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,803
Of course. If you have read the Bible, it's very decent to reject that wayward Rabbi with a God complex.

So whose side are you on, JC's or the snooty priests?
PS- What's a 'God complex'? If you mean JC claimed to be God, nah he never did- :p

Jesus said - "Only God knows when Judgment Day will be, I don't know myself" (Mark 13:32)
 

Wigi

Veteran
Joined
Aug 24, 2017
Messages
891
Of course. If you have read the Bible, it's very decent to reject that wayward Rabbi with a God complex.
"the light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. For everyone practicing evil hates the light and does not come to the light, lest his deeds should be exposed."
John 3:19‭-‬20
 

shankara

Star
Joined
Apr 23, 2018
Messages
1,322
Society cant even seem to agree that pornography and abortion is abhorrent. People even commit adultery and cheat on their partner nowadays with hardly any conviction. I was reading not that long ago that through entertainment the average person witnesses over thousands of deaths in their lifetime when before the age of television the average person could go their entire life without seeing somebody killed, yet we give full support to entertainment and entertainers that encourage adultery, lying, theft, murder, and all sorts of other evils. We live in an age where everyone does that which is right in their own eyes having their conscience seared as the Bible says. If someones conscience or nerves are seared that means they become numb and lose feeling.
There were also ages where people did atrocious things in the name of the christian god, things far worse and on a much grander scale than cheating on one's partner. I'm not saying that atheism is a particularly good tendency, but for many people it's basically just a reaction at seeing the horrors that have taken place justified by particular interpretations of the Bible. In fact many atheists have a heart, they have enough love to be sickened by the things which have taken place with the justification of "it's God's Will". You can talk in hypotheticals and give extreme examples of ideas which could come from a particularly ruthless person who (happens to be) an atheist, it doesn't change the fact that there exist genuinely virtuous and courageous atheists with real love for humanity. Of course the Protestant religion is so distorted that virtue is no longer even something you consider important.
 

Lyfe

Star
Joined
May 11, 2020
Messages
3,639
There were also ages where people did atrocious things in the name of the christian god, things far worse and on a much grander scale than cheating on one's partner. I'm not saying that atheism is a particularly good tendency, but for many people it's basically just a reaction at seeing the horrors that have taken place justified by particular interpretations of the Bible. In fact many atheists have a heart, they have enough love to be sickened by the things which have taken place with the justification of "it's God's Will". You can talk in hypotheticals and give extreme examples of ideas which could come from a particularly ruthless person who (happens to be) an atheist, it doesn't change the fact that there exist genuinely virtuous and courageous atheists with real love for humanity. Of course the Protestant religion is so distorted that virtue is no longer even something you consider important.
There are also people who have committed unspeakable evils in the name of lust, greed, covetousness, malice, deceit, foolishness, and evil thoughts. I guess I can blame the human heart?

Mark 7:21 For from within, out of the heart of men, proceed evil thoughts, adulteries, fornications, murders,
Mark 7:22 Thefts, covetousness, wickedness, deceit, lasciviousness, an evil eye, blasphemy, pride, foolishness:
Mark 7:23 All these evil things come from within, and defile the man.
 
Last edited:

Lyfe

Star
Joined
May 11, 2020
Messages
3,639
Not to mention if you were to judge humanity with the same stanards you judge God with with even half the measure you could come to the conclusion that human beings are not an inherently good species and are not even really fit as committers of evil deeds to judge God.
 

Lyfe

Star
Joined
May 11, 2020
Messages
3,639
Of course. If you have read the Bible, it's very decent to reject that wayward Rabbi with a God complex.
Of course. If you have read the Bible, it's very decent to reject that wayward Rabbi with a God complex.
Jesus said to judge him according to the deeds he had done. In the accounts of him he could raise the dead and even generate food to feed thousands out of virtually nothing. The angels would come down to minister to him. Yet you deduce these miracles as to a wayward rabbi with a God complex when it would stand to reason that anyone who could do such feats and claim to be the son of God that got his power from heaven must be something more than just a mere person of insignificance with a complex.
 
Last edited:

shankara

Star
Joined
Apr 23, 2018
Messages
1,322
There are also people who have committed unspeakable evils in the name of lust, greed, covetousness, malice, deceit, foolishness, and evil thoughts. I guess I can blame the human heart?

Mark 7:21 For from within, out of the heart of men, proceed evil thoughts, adulteries, fornications, murders,
Mark 7:22 Thefts, covetousness, wickedness, deceit, lasciviousness, an evil eye, blasphemy, pride, foolishness:
Mark 7:23 All these evil things come from within, and defile the man.
Yeah I get what you're saying, and this is why we need religion. Not to repress evil or anything like that, but to kindle the fire of devotion in the heart. Because the heart is not only darkness, it is also the source of love. Hence any religious process which stirs that devotion is a positive thing, and there is something of it even in those religions which have become separated from their source. In fact if it were not for sectarianism and the notion of "my god is the true god, yours is the false god", then much of the evil done in the name of religion would not have taken place. Nor would there be so many atheists, because there would be nothing to react against.

This is why we need to go beyond the sectarianism in which the world still finds itself, despite the efforts of various enlightened individuals to put an end to it. In fact it is also the heart which sees clearly, which can see beyond the apparent intellectual and doctrinal conflicts which tend to perplex the intellect.
 

Lyfe

Star
Joined
May 11, 2020
Messages
3,639
Yeah I get what you're saying, and this is why we need religion. Not to repress evil or anything like that, but to kindle the fire of devotion in the heart. Because the heart is not only darkness, it is also the source of love. Hence any religious process which stirs that devotion is a positive thing, and there is something of it even in those religions which have become separated from their source. In fact if it were not for sectarianism and the notion of "my god is the true god, yours is the false god", then much of the evil done in the name of religion would not have taken place. Nor would there be so many atheists, because there would be nothing to react against.

This is why we need to go beyond the sectarianism in which the world still finds itself, despite the efforts of various enlightened individuals to put an end to it. In fact it is also the heart which sees clearly, which can see beyond the apparent intellectual and doctrinal conflicts which tend to perplex the intellect.
I am a man of peace as Jesus tells his followers to if possible to be at peace with all men and even love them that spitefully use me and cast my name as evil. There is no need or even legitimate precedence for any evil to be done in the name of Christ as violence is unchristian. The Bible tells us to earnestly contend for the faith and reprove the deeds of darkness, to reprove, rebuke, and exhort with all long suffering and restore someone in error in the spirit of meekness. Paul denounced false gods and doctrines contrary to teaching, but it never led to him perpetrating violence. It was always done so peaceably and using Gods word as the foundation. The evil done in the name of Christ that many will point their finger at is really the evil of man acting according to his own harmful lust.
 
Top