BTS discussion thread

Kimiko2

Established
Joined
May 15, 2022
Messages
187
Ptd is one of their worst songs but anyone who says that is harassed and forced back into the hive/fandom.
Ptd is their absolute worst song and I think singing/performing that crap over and over with pained smiles on their faces is what pushed them over the edge and that's why they took this semi permanent hiatus plus enlistment

That song is enough to fuck anybody up it's horrendous

Yn and NJ sold their musical creativity for more western validation and accolades with promises of military exemption and a grammy and after all those awful performances of ptd they still didn't get the grammy or exemption and that's what made them go on hiatus imo

And like them or not but yn and NJ are the creative ones in the group with songwriting

From good songs like run,NO,spring day to butter pop garbage butter and ptd
 

Berrywon88

Star
Joined
Jun 23, 2021
Messages
2,594
Ptd is their absolute worst song and I think singing/performing that crap over and over with pained smiles on their faces is what pushed them over the edge and that's why they took this semi permanent hiatus plus enlistment

That song is enough to fuck anybody up it's horrendous
Yup, I think that was the final nail in the coffin. I've listened to a lot of music in my lifetime and I put ptd in the top 3 worst songs ever. Absolutely dreadful!
 
Joined
Mar 1, 2021
Messages
4,701
At the start when Korean drama industry was still in its immature stage they would make remakes of popular Japanese and Asian dramas. Some of their most popular dramas are adaptations of Japanese Mangas but most Koreaboos have no clue. Same thing happened with their pop music. 1st and 2nd gen K-POP groups were heavily inspired by Japanese idol and other music groups in terms of both sounds and fashion. Now starting third gen we started the trend of making idols look and act more and more like Anime characters. For 4th Gen the focus seemed to be on copying the vocaloids and Vtuber concept from Japan. Those who aren't ripping off Japan are looking towards America to figure out which trend to copy next
Why don't companies look internally for the next big trend? They only copy everyone else's work, but have a lot of untapped talent. America movies like the Money Heist are being remade, but that didn't do well with audiences.
 
Joined
Mar 1, 2021
Messages
4,701
Ptd is their absolute worst song and I think singing/performing that crap over and over with pained smiles on their faces is what pushed them over the edge and that's why they took this semi permanent hiatus plus enlistment

That song is enough to fuck anybody up it's horrendous

Yn and NJ sold their musical creativity for more western validation and accolades with promises of military exemption and a grammy and after all those awful performances of ptd they still didn't get the grammy or exemption and that's what made them go on hiatus imo

And like them or not but yn and NJ are the creative ones in the group with songwriting

From good songs like run,NO,spring day to butter pop garbage butter and ptd
That song pushed me out of the fandom. I was teetering on the edge and that was the last straw. Imagine performing that over and over and hearing it in your sleep. The group probably asked if they were serious when they were asked to sing it.
 
Joined
Mar 1, 2021
Messages
4,701
He looks sick and like he was forced to work when he should have been resting. It seems like t*t are declining health wise at a much faster rate than b*s did. They all look unwell to me and over worked. Every time I hear about them they're doing another cb or solo activity. And their leader, Soobin looks like he dropped a significant amount of weight on an already thin frame. His neck looks like it can barely hold his head now.
The only one with a normal body weight is Hk and they're bullying him to start dieting. The others are underweight and too small for their height. I used to worry about Yj the most, but Bg and Sb are declining faster than him. Sb is 6'2, and I wouldn't believe it if someone said he was over 130 lbs. His frame is large but he has no meat left. There's almost no muscle on his arms and legs.
 

cadiz

Star
Joined
Sep 28, 2018
Messages
1,999
The only one with a normal body weight is Hk and they're bullying him to start dieting. The others are underweight and too small for their height. I used to worry about Yj the most, but Bg and Sb are declining faster than him. Sb is 6'2, and I wouldn't believe it if someone said he was over 130 lbs. His frame is large but he has no meat left. There's almost no muscle on his arms and legs.
is this him? i just saw the article

[enter-talk] BEOMGYU SERIOUSLY SEEMS IN PAIN....






those companies really dont care about the health of the idols, the guy doing an interview and almost passing out
 

Beautiful

Star
Joined
Jun 9, 2022
Messages
1,110
There's something wrong with txt's Bg. I noticed his energy was off during the concert. He couldn't finish the interview today and had to leave early.

Actually there are more clips showing his illness or depression before only. But i think now it became serious now every one can see
By the first clip i know how fans are legends u know someone said he is going through breakup. When he clearly has health issues. And in 2 clip he gave indication that he is unwell.
Here u can see sb waist it not healthy for a growing men to be that thin
You can clearly see how thin his hands are specially his right hand. I understand the group dynamics but i genuinely think that sb and bg have true friendship bond. Sb can be rude sometimes to bg. But he is the only one who takes care of bg i think idk what goes behind. there are some behind clips sb taking care of bg. In whole tour he is holding and observing bg
 

Beautiful

Star
Joined
Jun 9, 2022
Messages
1,110
Here u can clearly say how staff is threatening him. He looks so feared. They are touching them unwantedly. And the one who said bg i love you weird. His eyes are way weird
When I came into this group i taught hk is only the weird one. But now everyone expect him are weird to me. Yg is whole different story. Boy seriously looks like soulless body just living means living. Bg i am fearing now a days boy became very quite in vlives. And when he comes near to camera all I can see is only skull. I can sound rude but here we are just commenting what we are seeing. When we know this much is happening why can't there parents and fans know. These should fans should spend time on observing idols instead of streaming 24/7
 
Last edited:

Beautiful

Star
Joined
Jun 9, 2022
Messages
1,110
Here they said he is having clash with schedule. But sb and yg are having tight schedule bcz of their brand advertisement. I think they are taking him to some consultant. Or something definitely going behind
 
Joined
Mar 1, 2021
Messages
4,701
is this him? i just saw the article

[enter-talk] BEOMGYU SERIOUSLY SEEMS IN PAIN....






those companies really dont care about the health of the idols, the guy doing an interview and almost passing out
Yes that's him and I'm so angry. He was almost passing out and at one point looked like he did faint. They're being overworked and who knows that else.
 

Kimiko2

Established
Joined
May 15, 2022
Messages
187
They are doing a huge concert in busan in October to get busan chosen in 2030 for the world expo

I was expecting jh to perform on some of the korean music shows as well but didn't happen yet

Jkay has yet to promote that ok but too bubblegum song with Charlie puke


Speaking of jkay he is extremely thin I'm pretty sure he has an eating disorder
He was a nice size and was still slender but with lean muscles and now he just looks way too think and pale
He looks unhealthy and bad,cheekbones are very hallow now and they weren't not too long ago
 

Laura755y

Star
Joined
Aug 10, 2021
Messages
2,568
They are doing a huge concert in busan in October to get busan chosen in 2030 for the world expo

I was expecting jh to perform on some of the korean music shows as well but didn't happen yet

Jkay has yet to promote that ok but too bubblegum song with Charlie puke


Speaking of jkay he is extremely thin I'm pretty sure he has an eating disorder
He was a nice size and was still slender but with lean muscles and now he just looks way too think and pale
He looks unhealthy and bad,cheekbones are very hallow now and they weren't not too long ago
God damn, he look awfull, when ur life style is fucked up, thats what u get. I feel sorry for his younger self tho, they truly fuck up them kids. Their staff look healthier than them.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Joined
Mar 1, 2021
Messages
4,701
Actually there are more clips showing his illness or depression before only. But i think now it became serious now every one can see
By the first clip i know how fans are legends u know someone said he is going through breakup. When he clearly has health issues. And in 2 clip he gave indication that he is unwell.
Here u can see sb waist it not healthy for a growing men to be that thin
You can clearly see how thin his hands are specially his right hand. I understand the group dynamics but i genuinely think that sb and bg have true friendship bond. Sb can be rude sometimes to bg. But he is the only one who takes care of bg i think idk what goes behind. there are some behind clips sb taking care of bg. In whole tour he is holding and observing bg
Bg is already tiny, so why aren't they making him eat more? He takes care of Sb, and Sb takes care of him. They have a friendship outside of the group. The only one who's doesn't have friends in the group is Yj. That's sickening how small both of them are. He's clearly out of energy in the twitter clip.
 
Top