Yeah, I did.
Since communism is defined as worker ownership over the means of production and since the USSR and China never allowed the workers to own the means of production, the USSR and China were not communist. They simply don't fit the definition.
Both the USSR and China said that they were working
towards communism and not that they were actually communist. Their ideology came from Leninism which said that a state capitalist dictatorship was the best way to communism. This was a blatant lie because it was obviously just a way to centralize power into the hands of an authoritarian leader.
Lenin implemented the NEP in the USSR.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Economic_Policy
The NEP was a policy of state capitalism which means that the state has control over everything. Here is a quote: Lenin characterized the NEP in 1922 as an economic system that would include "a free market and capitalism, both subject to state control" while socialized state enterprises were to operate on "a profit basis"
State capitalism is not communism because communism requires decentralization and worker's ownership... that's the exact opposite of state capitalism. The USSR was never a communist country, the workers did not control the means of production and it certainly wasn't decentralized or democratic.
Mecca, you clearly don't have any desire to actually understand how what you are describing
IS real communism and is based on the principles taught by Marx about achieving communism by the use of force if required.
A dictator and revolution are expected features of every government process where communism has been implemented according to Marx himself. It was his idea that the only way to avoid a revolution by force would be if capitalists handed over their property and rights by their own choice, which wasn't likely to happen. So the Bolshevik revolution was entirely what Marx envisioned. The dictatorship of Lenin inherited by Stalin was also expected as part of societies transition to communism or the objective of enslaving the world. The proletariat is a PC term for slave. This was all supported and promoted by Marx and Engels and because it is promoted by the founders, again propaganda is required to get people to accept this nonsense.
"Marx and Engles decided that it had become their manifest duty to see that the revolution was vigorously promoted. Why prolong the suffering? The old society was doomed. In the light of the principles discovered by Marx and Engels perhaps the race could be saved a dozen generations of exploitation and injustice simply by compressing this entire phase of social evolution into a single generation of violent readjustment"
There is the description of the Bolshevik revolution.
"They felt it could be done in three steps: First, by wiping out the old order. 'there is but one way of simplifying, shortening, concentrating the death agony of the old society as well as the bloody labor of the new world's birth Revolutionary Terror (Quoted from the Neue Rehinesche Zeuitung, by J.E. Le Rossignol in From Marx to Stalin, p. 231)' (Quoted in The Naked Truth as the above quote is, and the remaining quotes are as well).
"Second, the representatives of the working class must then set up a Dictatorship of the Proletariat. Joseph Stalin described the things that must be accomplished during this period of dictatorship:
1. completely suppress the old capitalist class.
2. Create a mighty army of 'defense" to be used "for the consolidation of the ties with the proletarian of other lands, and for the development and the victory of the revolution in all countries."
Number two can clearly be seen as progressing with NATO, the US, and the IDF operating in all parts of the world as a military presence, not including the cases where communism is being attempted in other countries like Venezuela, which has resulted in quick failure. This is still a very clearly active principle by Stalin inspired by Marx's teaching on the necessity of revolution.
"3. Consolidate the unity of the masses in support of the Dictatorship."
This is likely the reason the UN opposes the state of Israel to gain the support of the nations who oppose it. The UN is the vision of a central government for the communist empire and Israel is the capital.
"4. Establish universal socialism by eliminating private property and preparing all mankind for the ultimate adoption of full Communism."
This is clearly in the process as the banks own most of the homes in the US at the present time and you would only need to officially collapse the economy for private property to be a thing of the past almost overnight. Most of our services are being centralized by the government at the present time and private ownership and the possibility to buy a home or start a business have already been replaced for the most part. So if a communist government is what you want, we are almost there.
"Third, the final step is the transition from socialism to full Communism. Socialism is characterized by state ownership of land and all means of production. Marx and Engels believed that after a while, when class consciousness has disappeared and there is no further resistance to be overcome, the state will gradually wither any and then the property will automatically belong to all mankind "in common."
And, this is your definition of communism. Your Wikiquote is propaganda itself describing the post-revolution world that Marx described and trying to promote this as the real form of communism. It is describing the pipe dream that the world could transition into at some point after the destructive plan has forced everyone to accept that the vision of Marx and Engels as the best thing for all of mankind to accept. This final step is what is used in the propaganda to promote people to support communism and is the entire reason that communists need media in order to evangelize their ideology.
So real communism requires something similar to the Bolshevik revolution, followed by a dictatorship until people forget a time where they had rights and passively accept that what they know is the best it can be, which is a somewhat accurate representation of what is actually happening in the world right now. More accurate than any other suggestion of an agenda that exists. However, because communism is just a method of recruiting people to accept slavery, the final stage does not have to carry the title of communist. It only needs people to be willing to implement the ideology of a few with force if necessary.
Back to the representation in Hollywood. These steps also describe the setting for most of the dystopian representations presented in Hollywood right now. Revolution, dictatorship, new generation that doesn't know anything of the way the world was before. It mirrors the history of communism, yet does not openly express that it is doing so and creates different names and sets these things to happen in the future because it is propaganda. People in Hollywood have a one size fits all political view because they are hired to promote propaganda like this video perpetuates.