Our point was not that idols don’t participate in the production because seriously who expects that from them , they are idols not musicians, most cannot even sing properly. Our point was the the Kpop machine as a whole is not original and copies western music without bringing much new to the table. Hybe shamelessly just copies current top artists. Now they want to stop singing in their own langauge as well, so what remains?Why can't you understand something so simple? I am talking about idols not taking part in production of their music. Let me give you an example. Taylor swift is the most popular US artist right now and that woman owns her music. She writes lyrics to all her songs and often has credits for production as well. Compare that to Taeyeon one of the most popular female soloists in Korea whose only contribution in making of her albums is providing vocals. The same thing can be said about Jungkook who didn't take part in production of his own album. Artists who don't make their own music get criticized all the time and even American artists have been dragged for this. And this is not just us. Prince one of the most acclaimed musician of all time also dragged pop musicians who didn't participate in production of their own albums.
There are still some kpop companies that release a a different type music even though they also use western producers and songwriters, and it sounds like this
Let’s look at YG that don’t buy their songs because they have an in house producer at least (even though a lot of the songs sound the same)