Muslims can't divorce ourselves from jewish/israelite history though. Forget palestinians, the israelites first drove out the caananites
You can compare the caananites to the native americans....and you would have a very solid argument here..
except this was endorsed by our God, by Allah, the establishment of Israel is all over the Quran and a celebrated event.
Ethnic cleansing from God's orders..right? God decides to remove an entire nation from that land because of their 'sins' (the extent of which we do not know, but we know Allah is the best Judge).
I guess we can argue that this original version was endorsed by God and prophets so it was okay, but what modern israel did to palestinians is not endorsed by God or prophets and therefore, not okay.
Valid argument but it just isn't a strong one because it's still ethnic cleansing.
there are christians who literally think Jesus is the supreme controller behind modern israel, the one pulling the strings
so if israel decides to bomb palestinian homes, it is Jesus who plants the idea in their mind..they really think in these terms. So there's no point bringing God into this since it's very subjective. We can accept the fact that we all clearly believe in some type of ethnic cleansing and we're hypocrites if we accuse israel of the same thing we ultimately, deep down, believe in.
Also, it was their land first, romans kicked them out..the argument could be made that muslims should have given them the land back if we cared so much about ethnic cleansing..but we didn't, we kept it for ourselves under our control...
again, it's the same hypocrisy as the british deciding to take the land from ottomon rule but keep it and hand it to jews.
Do you guys not flipping see the point in all of this? our own hypocrisy?
The strongest argument is from the Quran though where in Surah 17 Allah tells THEM that He could make them a nation again if He Wills (not those words but in the context this is what it means).....Allah also warns them that if they sin He will punish them yet again.
So from a muslim perspective, if the jews became a nation again as they are today...that could only occur by Allah's command and it would be supported by Allah
ironic right? but at the same time they have a responsibility to behave themselves just like they did before...
Actually, this particular chapter of the Quran also contains the original promise of zion (messianic israel) in verse 104
BUT another one of the sickening ironies is that certain muslims themselves have deceitfully altered the meaning/interpretation of this verse to conceal it's obvious implication
look at these translations Surah 17 verse 104
Muhammed Habib Shakir
And We said to the Israelites after him: Dwell in the land: and when the promise of the next life shall come to pass, we will bring you both together in judgment.
Yusuf Ali
And We said thereafter to the Children of Israel, "Dwell securely in the land (of promise)": but when the second of the warnings came to pass, We gathered you together in a mingled crowd.
the problem is for other verses it might be that Yusuf Ali has the best translation, each translation differs and is obv a very personal interpretation. The implication here is that back when the jews wrote the Torah in arabic and the sahaba read it, the prophet SAW said "they write things with their own hands and say it is from Allah"
this did not mean the Torah was altered in form but in interpretation/meaning. The Quran itself tells us this too but it is a condemnation of the scribes (just like Jeremiah did). The irony is yet again that muslims translated/interpreted this very verse from the Quran.......by actually misinterpreting it to suggest 'the bible has been altered, do not trust it'..........ironic that the translator/interpretor was doing the same thing.
The more accurate meaning was
Mohsin Khan
And We said to the Children of Israel after him: "Dwell in the land, then, when the final and the last promise comes near [i.e. the Day of Resurrection or the descent of Christ ['Îsa (Jesus), son of Maryam (Mary) عليهما السلام on the earth], We shall bring you altogether as mixed crowd (gathered out of various nations). (Tafsir Al-Qurtubi,).
Pickthall (former christian convert to islam who understood the theme better)
And We said unto the Children of Israel after him: Dwell in the land; but when the promise of the Hereafter cometh to pass We shall bring you as a crowd gathered out of various nations.
of course it is our belief that the real messianic israel/zion (greater israel) will be fulfilled when Isa AS returns.
The reason ive made this entire point is to point out that us muslims talk about the establishment of 'greater israel' in a negative tone, as if somehow is an attck against islam, but is it really?
it's the same ultimate religion!!
I know for absolute sure that modern israel and it's owners and everything else will be removed from power because it's a major part of prophecy
@Etagloc (colgate) i have to remember that.
like what i talked about in our discussion.