The origin of transgender theories comes from the jewish community in europe in the 1920s.
en.wikipedia.org
en.wikipedia.org
Hirschfeld was born in
Kolberg in Pomerania (since 1945
Kołobrzeg, Poland), in an
Ashkenazi Jewish family, the son of a highly regarded physician and Senior Medical Officer Hermann Hirschfeld. In 1887–1888, he studied
philosophyand
philology in
Breslau (now
Wrocław, Poland), then from 1888 to 1892
medicine in
Strasbourg,
Munich,
Heidelberg, and
Berlin. In 1892, he earned his medical degree.
After his studies, he traveled through the United States for eight months, visiting the
World's Columbian Exposition in
Chicago, and living from the proceeds of his writing for German journals. During his time in Chicago, Hirschfeld became involved with the homosexual subculture in that city. Struck by the essential similarities between the homosexual subcultures of Chicago and Berlin, Hirschfeld first developed his theory about the universality of homosexuality across the world, as he researched in books and newspaper articles about the existence of gay subcultures in Rio de Janeiro, Tangier, and Tokyo. Then he started a
naturopathic practice in
Magdeburg; in 1896, he moved his practice to
Berlin-Charlottenburg.
. Yikes, it's like history is repeating itself....
Here is the thing though, he was an adult when he got involved with that community. Initially out of curiosity and perhaps genuine concern for those who committed suicide as he dealt with the fallout from such events with the surviving family. It seems like he was an early cruiser who then happened to write an article about it.
At the same time, Hirschfeld was greatly affected by the trial of
Oscar Wilde, which he often referred to in his writings. Hirschfeld was struck by the number of his gay patients who had
Suizidalnarben ("scars left by suicide attempts"), and often found himself trying to give his patients a reason to live.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnus_Hirschfeld#cite_note-FOOTNOTEBauer201748-12
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnus_Hirschfeld#cite_note-FOOTNOTEBauer201748-12
Again, Oscar Wilde would have STILL gone to court and STILL served time if he was tried today. The victims that came forward were children aged 12-14. Well under the age of consent by modern UK standards. In fact, if Wilde went to trial TODAY his sentence would be much harsher than buggery BECAUSE they were children. So no, this argument does not hold weight.
There are more layers to why a person commits suicide, being gay might contribute to it, being molested as a boy, neglected, abused, exposed to trauma... feeling inadequate and guilty for misplaced love and desire I think, are more serious matters that need to be addressed. "It's hard for a gay man to become old, since much of their lust/desire revolves around youth and vitality". If all you have is your "gayness" and that is solely based on physical appearance and attention that gives, then when it fades, depression begins. Loneliness, identity crisis, failure, etc. This doctor is a fine example of wanting to find some sort of niche that gets HIM attention while justifying his cruising the gay scenes in major cities on another person's dime. Fuck him. The fact that he was jewish has little bearing on this matter, beyond that he SHOULD KNOW BETTER. He read the Torah, but it was just another book to him.
IMO he is about as Jewish as a loaf of bread is the body of Christ.
Also he was a pseudo feminist, racist, and humanist. The trifecta of fail. Also for the record, he didn't return to Germany because he knew Hindenburg and Hitler were homophobic.
Here is the thing, the reason why the German Youth didn't just throw out the material but made a public spectacle of burning it was to tell the pedophilic, pederastic communities that the days of exploiting children and young teens was over. The youth were taking their youth back, they had a new identity, they had a reason to live. The material that was burned was part of a larger study that justified sexual deviations including p***philia. For once, the Nazi's were actually
right about destroying that stuff. It made the climate that weakened Germany from within.
It has nothing to do with religion, to say or even imply that this is a "jewish" perversion is anti-Semitic. This is a perversion straight up and has no religious, cultural, national, racial boundaries.
I also want to stress that persecution of gay adults is wrong. As an adult if you want to be gay, be gay. Be trans. Just stay the fuck away from the kids and teens. If you can't do that...